We like to share product recommendations with you and hope you like them! Just to make you aware Kitchen Gadgets Maven may collect a small share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page.
Good night sleep is the main pillar that supports you through the day. Choosing a proper bed for you is the first and most important step. When we all imagine going to bed after a long day, we all imagine sinking into a cloudy softness and immediately falling asleep. The reality is quite different. Many people sleep on their back or stomach or they have back pain. If you are one of these people, then you know that “sinking into a soft cloud” would cost you your next day. In this case, choosing a hard mattress is the best thing you can do for your sleep and your health.
An extra firm mattress is between 7 and 9 on a scale of 10. In many studies, it has proven to release lower back pains and help people be more mobile throughout the day. Also, people who sleep on their stomach claim “the firmer the bed, the better the sleep” since it won’t let them sink and thus sleep in a very unnatural and uncomfortable position.
We’ve reviewed the most popular extra firm mattresses to help you make the best decision since buying a mattress is a costly investment, but it pays out in the long run.
Our Reviews of 5 Best Extra Firm Mattresses
- The Flippable Extra Firm Mattress – Plank by Brooklyn Bedding
- Super Cool Hybrid – Brooklyn Aurora
- Luxurious Extra Firm Memory Foam – Loom and Leaf by Saatva
- Extra-firm Mattress For Heavier Sleepers – Winkbeds
- Extra-firm Hybrid For Heavier People – Titan by Brooklyn Bedding
- The Importance of The Hard Firmness
- Different Levels of Firmness
- What Firmness fits you
- How to Choose The Best Extra Firm Mattress
- What Is A Good Budget To Spend
Key Features: Flippable design offers two firm levels firm and extra firm; very breathable; optional cooling panel; 10-year warranty: made in the USA.
Price Range: $559-$999
Risk-Free Trial: Try it risk-free for 120 nights
The Plank is pretty much the firmest mattress on our list. It is for stomach sleepers and those who need extra support. When laying on the supportive foams you’ll get a feeling like you are floating above the bed, so people who sleep on their stomach or back won’t feel like sinking and will enjoy an evening of cool sleep. The firm side is somewhere 8 out of 10 on the scale and the extra firm side is somewhere 9 out of 10.
The Plank mattress is a polyfoam mattress constructed of 4 layers, starting from the firmest side:
- 0.75-inch layer of quilted polyfoam to give you comfort and pressure relief
- 2-inch TitanFlex foam a proprietary foam resembling latex
- 7-inch high-density foam which is a standard base for foam mattresses
- 1.5-inch quilted polyfoam for the firm top side.
- It has two sides of firmness to choose from. In case the one side doesn’t work for you, you can always flip it over.
- You can add a cooling panel when ordering. It will cost you around $250, but if you are a hot sleeper, you’ll be grateful.
- It’s made of foam so it will give you some cushion and won’t feel like you’re sleeping on an actual plank.
- You will feel some motion from your partner, so it’s not the best at it.
- Neither side has the best edge support. When you sit on the edge, it collapses a bit. And if you like sleeping on the edge you might feel like falling off.
- The firm side is best for back sleepers. It allows a slight sink of the hips to give a nice arch of the spine.
- The extra firm side is best for the stomach and heavyweight sleepers. It gives just the right support and doesn’t let you sink making your sleep too hot for your liking.
Key Features: Hybrid of foam and coil; great cooling properties; 10-year warranty
Price Range: $800-$1,700
Risk-Free Trial: Try it risk-free for 120 nights
The Aurora Brooklyn hybrid mattress is made of innovative technology creating a latex alternative foam. This technology keeps the cost low while still giving you a mattress that is long-lasting and responsive. Aurora will have you sleeping cool during the whole night because of its cooling properties not only in the upper layers but also in the coil system that will dissipate the heat. The firmness of the mattress feels somewhere 7 out of 10 on the scale.
The Aurora firm mattress has a construction of 5 layers of foams and coils:
- The 1.5-inch layer of CopperFlex Foam with TitanCool cooling surface making it both extremely responsive and super cool to sleep on.
- 2-inch layer of breathable Visco Gel Memory Foam great for isolating motion giving additional support and deep comfort.
- 8-inch thick Quantum Edge Pocketed Coil System in its core to allow great support, easy movement, heat dispersion and it minimizes motion transfer.
- A 1-inch layer of Dense Base Foam as a solid and firm foundation helping keep the supportive coils in place while they do their job.
- Great heat dispersion that allows it to be cool for the whole night. All of the layers use the TitanCool technology, and the very top is infused with TitaniumGel for better breathability.
- Very good edge support due to the coils being edge to edge. The Aurora has reinforced edges so whether you like sleeping on the edge or with a partner you won’t feel like falling off.
- It keeps you afloat on the mattress making it easy to turn and ads to the cool sleeping.
- It’s not as firm as the Plank mattress so if you are a heavyweight sleeper you should look for a firmer bed
- Although the coils absorb most of the motions, you will still feel some disturbances from your partner. It won’t be much, but if you have light sleep it might bother you.
- Back sleepers – it has the right hip sinkage giving a good pressure relief
- Stomach sleepers – it supports proper spine alignment so you won’t experience awkward spine curves
- Hot sleepers – the top layers are infused with cooling technology making it perfect for people who are likely to overheat while sleeping.
Key Features: Organic cotton cover; good pressure relief; luxurious materials; 15-year warranty
Price Range: $849-$1,899
Risk-Free Trial: Try it risk-free for 120 nights
The Loom and Leaf mattress by Saatva is by far the firmest memory foam mattress on our list. It is a luxury mattress whose supportive foam and organic cotton cover will give you comfort constructed to give you the necessary firm support. It will also keep you cool during the night due to its property to properly disperse heat. The Relaxed Firm is somewhere 7 or 7.5 out of 10 on the scale, but the Firm option is a proper extra firm mattress scoring 9 out of 10 on the scale.
The Loom and Leaf mattress is constructed entirely out of foam which lays in 5 layers:
- Under the quilted cover, there is a 2-inch layer of gel memory foam allowing airflow
- The 2.5-inch layer of visco-elastic memory foam designed to help with cooling and spinal support
- 2-inch layer of denser memory foam for deep pressure relief and contouring support
- 2-inch transition loft pad, a layer serving as a transition from the support foam below
- 5.5-inch standard, base polyfoam layer
- A firm mattress with the comfort of memory foam
- Little to no motion transfer so it’s a great choice for couples
- Sleeps cool due to its use of gel in the foam, the convoluted pockets, and the cooling gel panel
- It allows sinkage since it’s entirely made of memory foam so if you are a heavier person you should probably go for a hybrid mattress.
- Slow responsiveness makes the change of positions a bit uncomfortable, so again, if you are a heavy person and not accustomed to memory foam, you will probably feel stuck.
- Stomach sleepers – since it’s made of memory foam, it will easily adjust to your body and give the right support so you won’t feel uncomfortable curvature of the spine
- Allergy sufferers – the cover is made of natural cotton and it doesn’t retain moisture so it won’t cause skin rashes
- People who prefer the feel of memory foam – if you are a person who enjoys the slight cradling of memory foam while giving your body necessary support, the Loom & Leaf mattress is your choice.
Key Features: Designed specifically for heavy sleepers; good pressure relief; zoned spine support; very breathable; lifetime warranty
Price Range: $1,249-$1,999
Risk-Free Trial: Try it risk-free for 120 nights
The Firm Plus model by Winkbeds is the best hard mattress for heavy sleepers. Its construction can support active usage of up to two heavy persons without sagging. This is a hybrid mattress with a quilted cover and two layers of coils for extra support. This mattress made our list because of its high-quality construction and its ability to offer comfort and support. The firmness of the mattress feels somewhere 8 out of 10 on the scale.
The Firm Plus mattress is constructed of 6 layers, of which 2 are coils:
- Under the Tencel cover, there is a 1-inch layer of gel-infused Hypersoft foam which helps to pull heat away from your body
- 1-inch layer of Premium Gel foam which also helps with keeping you sleep cool
- The 2.5-inch layer of individually wrapped micro coils encased in foam, they help in providing comfort and to change positions
- A 1-inch layer of high-density foam called the LumbarLayer it prevents sagging of the lower back helps in spinal ligament and serves as a transition layer between the micro-coils and the solid coil core
- 7.5-inch support layer composed of: individually wrapped pocket coils arranged in seven zones to give great support and spine alignment; and edge support layer encompassing the coils for a great edge support
- 2-inch layer of support foam at the base which is flat and solid giving all the other layers the perfect sturdy foundation.
- The two layers of coils that allow airflow and the two top layers of gel-infused foam make this bed for heavier people and hot sleeper a cool heaven
- Because of its construction, this is a very durable mattress
- Great edge support due to its reinforcing edge layer made of edge-specific coils surrounding that the pocket coils
- Little to no motion transfer owing to the two layers of coils making it great for couples
- Not very comfortable for side sleepers even the heavier ones. This is still a very hard mattress and even if you are a large person the pressure on the shoulders and hips will give you discomfort.
- Heavyweight sleepers – it will keep you afloat but comfortable.
- People with back issues – it’s sandwich-like construction and zoned pocket coils will give your back the proper alignment and release pressure points
- Couples – it doesn’t transfer motion so your partner can toss and turn without worrying and it’s great for couples where one partner is heavyweight and the other is lighter
Key Features: Great for heavyweight sleepers; good pressure relief; 10-year warranty
Price Range: $699-$1,249
Risk-Free Trial: Try it risk-free for 120 nights
The Titan extra firm mattress by Brooklyn Bedding is yet another mattress designed for heavier people. We know how hard it must be to hunt for such a mattress and that’s the reason why it made our list. It’s a great extra firm mattress and unlike the Plank, it’s a hybrid of foam and coils. You can order it with a cooling top panel that is sewed onto the top or Talalay topper. The mattress sleeps very firm so if you are a person under 300 lbs it will feel 9 out of 10 on the scale, but if you are heavier than it will feel somewhat softer 7.5 out of 10.
Titan has a construction of 4 layers of foam and coils:
- 1-inch layer of gel memory foam that helps you sleep cool and can withstand body impressions making changing positions very easy
- 2-inch layer of TitanFlex foam making the mattress very responsive and assists in point pressure relief
- 6-inch layer of individually encased TitanCaliber coils that provides great support and inhibits motion transfer
- 2-inch layer of high-density foam that makes a sturdy foundation for the coils while they compress and ads to durability
- Very low motion transfer – the combination of coils and dense foam makes great motion transfer barrier, so if your partner tosses and turns they will not disturb your dream
- Great edge support – if you like sleeping on the edge or you are sharing your bed the edge to edge coil layer gives just the right edge enforcement you won’t feel like falling off
- Can be preordered with a cooling top panel – if you are a hot sleeper or just like a cool feel, we recommend you preorder the Titan with a cooling top panel that is sowed onto the mattress.
- It feels more towards medium-firm for quite heavy people – if you are in the range of 300-500 lbs your weight will pull down the mattress thus altering its firmness. In this case, you might want to look for a more supportive mattress like Winkbeds
- Not comfortable for back sleepers – even if you are heavier the Titan won’t let your hips sink enough to enable you a comfortable sleep.
- Heavy people – Titan will give a firm feel even to lager people giving the right support to your body
- Stomach sleepers – if this is your preferred sleeping position, this mattress won’t let your hips sink too far giving your spine the proper alignment
- Hot sleepers – even without the cooling panel, this is still an extra firm mattress and won’t let you sink very much into it keeping the contact surface at a minimum, plus the coils allow airflow while the gel infused foam keeps you cool
There are numerous benefits that give advantage to an ultra-firm mattress before models with lower points on the scale.
Health Benefits Of Firm Beds:
- Proper back support – Hard mattresses are best for people with lower back and neck pain, and joint issues. They give significant support during your rest time so people in this group find it very comfortable. Alos back and stomach sleepers love it.
- Spine alignment – One of the main reasons people chose extra firm mattresses is that they help with proper spine alignment. Very firm mattresses are chosen by the group of people mentioned above for this very reason.
- Muscle relaxation – A proper spine alignment reduces pressure on your pressure points. This leads to relaxed muscles and a deeper state of sleep. Buying an extra firm mattress will give you the support your spine and joints need and you’ll be fresher in the morning because your whole body will relax during the night.
- Proper distribution of weight – A firm model won’t let your body sink, but it will evenly distribute your body weight and in this way reduce pressure from pressure points.
Advantages Of Firm Beds
- Affordable price – Most firm mattresses are composed of few soft layers which are thinner than the soft ones have. This production process is much cheaper and it lowers the end price a buyer is paying.
- Durability – Firm beds have a longer lifespan and are more resistant to sagging and drooping due to its built. The layers for extra firm beds are made of solid materials to correspond to the rigid support construction.
- It sleeps cooler – Firm mattresses are also good for hot sleepers. They don’t allow you to sink in so the area between your body and the mattress it’s kept at its minimum. This prevents the mattress to preserve heat and keeps your sleep undisturbed.
- Better edge support – The rigid construction of the firm beds gives enhanced edge support preventing sag on the sides. This is great if you like to sleep on the edge of the bed or you share it with a partner or pet. And anyway, no one likes a sagged edge to sit on while putting your socks on.
- Fresher smell – The denser materials of which the layers are made to keep the mattress less prone to odors since they easily aerate. This lowers the chances of outgassing and fungus sprouting.
- Lightweight – Extra firm mattresses are composed of few thin layers. That’s why they are lighter than the softer ones, so in case you want to flip, rotate or simply move the mattress around you’ll need quite less effort to do so.
Since firmness can be very subjective based on individual preferences, the mattress industry has agreed upon a universal firmness scale. The scale is from 1 to 10 where 1 is a very soft even sinking feel and 10 is a very hard surface, such as a plank.
Mattresses are divided into 3 groups:
- Soft mattresses are 3 to 5 out of 10 – very soft and plushy, give a sinkage.
- Medium mattresses are 5 to 7 out of 10 – these are more balanced m mattresses, give less sinkage, and more weight distribution.
- Firm or hard mattresses are 7 to 9 out of 10 – they give no sinkage, but rather a floating feeling.
(Note: Some mattress brands don’t use this scale, but rather a reverse one where 1 is solid rock. Be mindful to consult with reviews or a salesperson before proceeding to buy.)
If you are a person that is interested in buying a mattress from the upper end of the scale, you’ll find there are three kinds of firm mattresses:
- Extra firm mattress.
They all have their own purposes. Medium-firm ones are the most popular. Firm ones are slightly tougher ones but still have some cushion. The extra firm mattresses are the most sturdy ones and most wanted by back and stomach sleepers, people with lower back, neck and joint issues, and overweight or heavy people.
- Medium-firm mattresses are mostly fit for around 80% of the population. They are best suited for combo sleepers, mostly side sleepers.
- Firm mattresses are most preferable by back and stomach sleepers because it gives the necessary support the spine needs to achieve the natural curves. They are also great for hot sleepers.
- Extra firm mattresses are recommended for back and joint pain sufferers, even by doctors. In some cases, they are recommended for elderly people because changing positions on an ultra-firm bed are less painful because the body doesn’t sink. Heavy persons (BMI is 30 or more) are also great candidates for a very hard mattress because they distribute the body weight more evenly, give proper back support, and don’t retain temperature.
If you’ve set your mind for a very firm mattress, here are some criteria to consider before buying:
Split top side firmness – Just like sleeping on a softer bed causes you discomfort and most probably pain, it is very likely that the same thing happens to your partner from sleeping on a very hard bed. In this case, it’s best to look for a mattress that has the left and right side with different firmness levels. This way you can both have a relaxing good night’s sleep together.
Consider flippable mattress – Flippable mattresses come in two different firmness levels on each side. They might be slightly more expensive, but you’ll get two mattresses in one just in case the extra firm one doesn’t work for you anymore, or for the time being.
Pillows matter – To get the best from your firm bed it is very important to choose the right pillow. It is recommended to get a higher and firmer one because the soft ones will not give you the right neck support. Very often brands have discount promotions on pillows when buying a mattress so look for one.
Use the risk-free trials – Many brands offer extended risk-free trials, especially if you’re buying online. Use this time to assess which is the right firmness for you. You’ll have plenty of time to do so since they last around 90-120 nights. That’s three to four months to decide if it’s the right fit and return it with a full refund.
Mind the warranty – Always remember to check the warranty coverage. Many brands will replace a defective mattress. One of the main defects is sagging below the specified level. Should your mattress droop below that level, use the warranty to ask for a replacement. Also, check what other defects the warranty covers, the longer the list the better the mattress is.
How much you should pay for a mattress isn’t an easy answer. Mattresses are directly linked to your health so we advise not to be stingy. It is true that you can find to buy a tacky mattress as low as a couple of hundred. But also there are super hybrid mattresses that go up to $8,000 with all the bells and whistles.
Truth is, you’ll probably find a good mattress in the mid-range price $700-$1,600. This is especially true if you are shopping online since online retailers don’t have as many expenses as the in-store do.
Just avoid paying less than the average, cause you’ll probably end up with a mattress made of second-rate materials and lousy craftsmanship. In the end, you get what you pay.
- Best Book Lights for Reading in Bed: 2020 Reviews - June 8, 2020
- The Best Foundation for Memory Foam Mattress: 2020 Reviews - June 8, 2020
- Best Extra Firm Mattress: A Complete 2020 Buyer’s Guide - June 5, 2020