Getting the best sleep possible is an incredibly important thing. Good sleep will leave you feeling rested, refreshed, and ready for the day. Bad sleep will negatively affect your health as well as your overall mood. You might even go through life feeling like you’re in a fog, because if you don’t sleep well you’ll end up feeling constantly tired. This makes choosing the right mattress imperative. If you’re someone who wants something on the softer side of the mattress firmness scale, this is the guide for you. Despite the fact that most mattresses these days tend to be medium firmness, there are plenty of great soft mattresses out there. The best soft mattress for you is out there – you just need to find it and you’ll be on your way to better sleep in no time.
One of the things you need to know if you’re looking for a plush, softer bed is that it’s hard to find one in the typical mattress store. Those stores are aimed at the typical mattress shopper, who typically prefers a firmer bed for a variety of reasons (e.g. they have back pain). This is not to say that you won’t find a soft mattress – you just need to know where to look. This guide will give you all the information you need to make an informed purchase. At the end, we share our thoughts on the best soft mattress of 2018.
Quick Picks for the Best Soft Mattress
- Best Overall — Nolah
- Flippable — Layla
- Luxury — Eight Sleep Mars+
- Value — Brooklyn Bedding Signature
Later in this guide, we go in depth discussing why these were chosen for our list of top soft mattresses and much more.
Who Benefits from a Soft Mattress?
Like with every type of mattress, a softer bed will benefit some people more than others. Things like whether you’re a back sleeper or a side sleeper, your body weight, and any health concerns will determine whether you should have a soft mattress or a firmer one. So, who are the softest mattresses designed for?
Side sleepers – as soft beds will hug your curves, while still offering support, they are a popular choice among side sleepers. While soft beds can still be used in other sleep positions, if you sleep on your stomach, having a soft mattress can cause you to feel less supported in your mid-section. This can end up causing lower back pain, so stomach sleepers should be cautious when opting for a soft bed.
Petite Sleepers – The softest mattress is going to be better suited to sleepers that are around or under 150 pounds. While firmer mattresses require some weight to create sinkage, a soft bed will create sinkage faster. For lighter sleepers, this creates a higher level of comfort and pressure relief.
Sleepers without Back Problems – Back pain is a huge problem for many people. If you have back pain, you’re typically going to do better with a medium or firm mattress.
Who Shouldn’t Sleep on a Soft Mattress?
Soft mattresses aren’t right for everyone. Some people will do better on a medium or even firm mattress. The most common groups that should avoid soft mattresses are:
Sleepers with Back Pain – if you regularly experience back pain upon waking up, it could be due to the position you are sleeping in. Or, it could be because your mattress is too soft. Harvard research suggests that those with back pain should avoid very soft – and very hard – mattresses, and opt for a medium firm or firm mattress.
Overweight Sleepers – if you are overweight, or simply just weigh a lot due to your large frame, you should also likely avoid soft mattresses. These ultra-plush mattress options tend to provide too much give/sag for heavier sleepers, which can lead to back problems.
What is the Best Soft Mattress of 2018?
We’ve personally tested many of the top beds on the market while also researching countless reviews from real consumers to help you find the best soft mattress for your particular needs. You can learn more about our credentials and our criteria for making our picks further down in this article.
Some of our favorite soft mattresses include:
Key Features: 4x better pressure relief than memory foam; 100% temperature neutral to keep you cool
Price Range (Twin-Cal. King): $549-$1069 (+ save $125 with promo code SLEEPZOO!)
Risk-Free Trial: Try it risk-free for 120 nights
Created from Nolah Air Foam, Nolah mattresses are exceptionally responsive. You’ll find your new mattress to have the comfort you’d get from a memory foam bed, and you’ll still have the responsiveness and bounce you’d find in memory foam, as well. Nolah foam includes tons of tiny air pockets that will help to contour your body no matter your size. This makes it a good choice if you’re on the heavier side, but still want a mattress that feels softer.
A 15-year warranty comes with each Nolah mattress. You also get a 4-month risk-free trial. This gives you plenty of time to ensure that you chose the right mattress for you. Should you need to return your mattress, Nolah offers both free shipping and there is no return charge, especially during your trial. Also, to be charitable, every time a Nolah mattress is sold, Nolah donates the required funds to ensure that an animal is adopted from a shelter.
SleepZoo Exclusive: use promo code SLEEPZOO at checkout to save $125!
Key Features: Copper-infused memory foam diffuses heat and makes it one of the coolest soft mattresses for sleepers; mattress is flippable with one soft side and one medium-firm side
Price Range (Twin-Cal. King): $499-$999
Risk-Free Trial: Try it risk-free for 120 nights
The Layla Mattress is one of the best soft mattresses on the market. What’s unique about it is that it’s also one of the best medium firm mattresses. How does that work? Well, Layla can be flipped over, with a soft side and a firm side. Depending on your preferences, you can sleep on the soft side or the firm side. Regardless of which side you use, Layla is impressively supportive – providing great response in deep compression areas where support is most needed.
As you can see from the picture above, the Layla mattress is made up of 4 layers: copper infused memory foam, convoluted air flow foam, supportive base foam, and copper infused memory foam. If you’re wondering if you read that right, you did – there is copper in this mattress. Copper is an excellent conductor, which basically means that it can suck up the heat that your body creates through the night, and distribute it throughout the mattress. This can help keep you cool at night, and is particularly awesome in warm climates. Copper also has antimicrobial properties, which helps keep your mattress clean.
Each Layla mattress comes with a 120-night risk-free trial – which means if you are not satisfied, you can return your mattress at any time during the first 4 months. Overall, Layla offers fantastic value – especially given the affordable price, which ranges from $499 to $999 depending on the mattress size.
Eight Sleep Mars+
Key Features: Smart technology tracks and analyzes your sleep, offering tips to improve sleep quality; hybrid design offers comfort of memory foam with support of innerspring
Price Range (Twin-Cal. King): $1299-$1599
Risk-Free Trial: Try it risk-free for 100 nights
The Eight Sleep Mars+ is a fantastic mattress from an up-and-coming manufacturer. It’s the softest model offered by Eight, however it tends to fall in the middle of the firmness scale in our tests. Therefore, it’s best for those who like a soft-ish mattress, but also want the additional support of a slightly firmer mattress.
The Mars+ is a hybrid mattress, which means it has both coils and foam. This provides the best of both worlds – excellent support from the coils, and premium comfort/softness from the foam. The foam is made of reactive polyester, which is designed to have the bounce of latex with the soft feel of foam – making it a good mattress for sex – while the mattress also offers impressive motion isolation, making it a good bed for couples in general.
While the hybrid design, premium poly foam and impressive support make the Mars+ a great all-around mattress, the real value of this bed in our opinion is the smart features. The Mars+ comes with a smart mattress cover that tracks 15 different factors relating to your sleep quality and health. It tracks heart rate, respiratory rate, deep sleep, sleep cycles, sleep duration, and more. It even features a smart alarm that can detect when your body enters a lighter sleep cycle, making it easier to wake feeling rested. The Mars+ can integrate with your smart home system, can be controlled by your smartphone, and can even regulate the temperature of your bed.g
All in, the Eight Sleep Mars+ is an ultra-premium smart mattress at an affordable price. It’s priced from $1300, with a 100-day risk-free trial. Eight also offers an industry-leading 10-year warranty.
Our Eight Sleep Mars+ review has all the details you’re looking for about this technology-driven mattress. And for those looking for a great deal, you can grab an Eight Sleep coupon code and save $50 with code SLEEPZOO at checkout.
Brooklyn Bedding Signature
Key Features: Multiple firmness levels available so you can find the right mattress for your preference; great value at its price point
Price Range (Twin-Cal. King): $425-$900
Risk-Free Trial: Try it risk-free for 120 nights
If you’re looking for a good deal, Brooklyn Bedding has their own factory, so they can offer very competitive pricing. Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattresses have 10” of multi-layered foam. The three layers include the base support, a layer of Dunlap latex, and a layer of Talalay foam. The latex will offer some bounce to your bed, and the combination of foams offers a nice cool bed that ensures you won’t sleep hot. They offer several different firmness levels, with a premium soft mattress available. If you’re looking for the best soft mattress, this is definitely a contender.
You’ll receive a 4-month risk-free trial with each new mattress purchased. Your mattress should be delivered within four days of ordering. If you don’t like it, just let customer service know during the trial period, and you can return it risk-free. A 10-year warranty is included, so if you keep your mattress you can be assured it’s protected should anything happen.
Thinking about trying Brooklyn Bedding’s Signature mattress and want to save? Check out the latest Brooklyn Bedding coupon codes.
While these are our picks for the best soft mattress, there are certainly others on the market. If you didn’t quite find what you were looking for, or if you’re looking for another type of mattress altogether, we recommend checking out our Mattress Guide. We are also happy to answer reader questions!
You’ve seen our recommendations – but why should you trust us? How are we any better than the average mattress salesman, or your buddy Mike who just bought a new mattress?
Experience – our team is lead by Chris Brantner, Certified Sleep Science Coach whose expert opinions have been featured in the likes of Bustle, Brit + Co, Fatherly, and more.
Testing – our team has spent countless hours testing various mattress models from many of the top online mattress brands. We worked hard to individually analyze the unique characteristics of each model, breaking down pros and cons and identifying which models made the most sense for our readers.
Research – to verify and expand on our own findings, we conducted extensive online research on each model we reviewed. We looked not only at manufacturer specs to identify materials, manufacturing processes and durability, but also at hundreds of third-party customer reviews. By analyzing research from Consumer Reports, combined with the opinions of hundreds of verified customers on Amazon and other online retailers, we were able to round out our own findings and ensure that no detail was missed.
Interest – unlike many websites who focus solely on mattress reviews, we have a genuine interest (okay, obsession) with sleep. We regularly research and report on sleep science, sleep tips and sleep news. We want our readers to get better, more restful sleep, and we realize that that pursuit involves more than just finding the right mattress.
How We Chose the Best Soft Mattress
With over 35 MILLION mattresses shipped each year and literally thousands of different models on the market, one might wonder how we went about choosing the best soft beds for our readers. We utilized a combination of factors, including:
Softness – shocking, we know. The first aspect we looked at was the actual softness of the bed. We looked at how the manufacturer labeled the mattress – soft, ultra soft, plush, ultra plush, etc. and then compared that to our own findings, and the reports of consumers in soft mattress reviews. In some cases, the manufacturer’s stated category was not accurate enough in our opinion, so we went the extra mile to ensure it was the right softness level for this guide.
Materials – we looked at the materials and manufacturing processes that each mattress company used to produce their beds. Soft mattresses sometimes have sagging issues later in their life, so it’s essential to select a mattress that is well made. Cheap soft mattresses might be tempting – and they will even be comfortable initially – but you will find their lifespan to be quite short. We chose only models made using the best materials, to ensure longevity.
Motion Isolation – since many of our readers share their beds with a partner and want a good mattress for couples, we picked mattresses that have good “motion isolation”, or a lack of “motion transfer”. This essentially refers to the level of movement in the rest of the bed when you get up. When you get out of a bed with good motion isolation, your partner likely won’t even notice, even if they are a light sleeper.
Value – we like finding great deals for our readers. While some people might buy mattresses that cost more than a new car, we recognize that most of our readers want to find a great mattress at a great price. Therefore, price played a major role in our decision making process – but it certainly wasn’t the main factor we looked at. Regardless, all our picks represent a fantastic value at their price point.
Perks – even the best soft mattress is nothing without a solid manufacturer warranty, customer support, etc. So, beyond looking at the mattress itself, we put a magnifying glass on the manufacturer and their policies. We looked for manufacturers and retailers that offered good warranties, extended free trial periods, and helpful customer support.
Latest posts by Ashtyn Evans (see all)
- President’s Day Mattress Sale Guide: 2018’s Best Mattress Deals - February 9, 2018
- What’s the Best Mattress for the Money? (2018) - February 8, 2018
- What’s the Best Mattress for Arthritis and Aching Joints? - February 8, 2018